The Pandemic of Private Solutions to Public Problems: The Case of Water Supply and Access

The Kenyan Constitution Article 43(1)(d) explicitly guarantees every person the right to “clean and safe water in adequate quantities.” Concurrently, the Water Act 2016 delegates service delivery to county governments while retaining regulatory oversight through the Water Services Regulatory Board (WASREB). Nairobi’s population exceeds 4.4 million, yet formal water supply infrastructure has lagged behind demographic expansion and rapid urban densification. The existing water sources yield approximately 525,000–580,000 m³/day against a metropolitan demand exceeding 850,000 m³/day. To manage the structural deficit, the main utility operates a rigid water rationing program, with formal residential areas often receiving piped water only 1 to 3 days per week. The situation is worse in informal settlements housing the bulk of residents.

Many years of underinvestment in public water supply have led to the emergence and growth of private solutions, evidenced by a large number of water bowsers (a common joke being “the blue economy”), and an increasing number of borehole drilling service providers. The rich are drilling boreholes as a coping mechanism, while the poor have become victims of the “Poverty Penalty,” where residents pay significantly more per liter than connected middle-class residents. A 20-liter jerrican costs between KES 10 to KES 30 during scarcity, translating to unit costs of KES 500–1,500/m³, compared to NCWSC’s baseline subsidized tariff of approximately KES 53/m³.

The environmental and health impacts are just beginning to show. Unchecked groundwater abstraction in Nairobi’s residential and commercial hubs (e.g., Kilimani, Westlands, Industrial Area) is driving regional water tables down by 1 to 2.5 meters annually, forcing developers to drill into deeper volcanic aquifers (250–400+ m) (Oiro et al., 2020), and incurring higher energy and operational pumping costs. Concurrently, natural volcanic geology in areas like Karen elevates groundwater fluoride levels (F−) to between 1.5 mg/L and over 8 mg/L, far exceeding the WHO safety threshold of 1.5 mg/L, placing unmanaged consumers at high risk for dental and skeletal fluorosis (Ashong et al., 2024). Beyond fluoride, Nairobi’s groundwater faces severe microbiological and chemical contamination, driven by poor liquid and solid waste management, and volcanic weathering. Studies across Nairobi County by our team reveal widespread total coliform contamination, with up to 34% of sampled boreholes containing E. coli, while shallow wells near high-density areas record elevated nitrate levels exceeding the WHO safety limit of 50 mg/L. Furthermore, heavy metals like lead routinely surpass the 0.01 mg/L WHO threshold near industrial zones and informal mechanic clusters. High total dissolved solids forces private operators to install capital-intensive reverse osmosis systems prior to use.

Overall, the quest for private solutions to public problems has contributed to environmental and social challenges that are quickly threatening the right to a clean and healthy environment as enshrined in the Constitution. Albeit late, the government has stepped up efforts to invest in public infrastructure aimed at augmenting bulk supply, reducing distribution losses, and expanding pro-poor access to satisfy Article 43(1)(d) constitutional mandates. The flagship Northern Collector Tunnel (Phase 1) targets approximately 140,000 m³/day of raw water into Nairobi’s supply grid to shrink the daily deficit. Concurrently, the French Development Agency (AFD)-funded Western Nairobi Water Project constructs a 19.7 km bulk transmission line and a 5,500 m³ storage reservoir in Karen to stabilize network pressure across underserved western suburbs. To dismantle informal cartel pricing, the Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company (NCWSC) deploys automated prepaid Water ATMs and communal kiosks in low-income settlements like Kibera and Mathare, delivering municipal-tariff water directly to vulnerable populations. Finally, utilities are establishing District Metered Areas (DMAs) and leveraging GIS network mapping to reduce Non-Revenue Water (NRW) from its 45%–50% baseline, while the Water Resources Authority (WRA) enforces strict volumetric metering and abstraction limits to protect long-term aquifer recharge.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top